Use This Hub to Check the Evidence
This rebuilt page combines the newer Right First Time UK transparency layout with the detailed material from the original site. The original information, evidence routes and source links are kept below rather than being replaced.
1. Read the information
Use the restored sections below for the detailed subject guide and background.
2. Open the evidence
Source, evidence and information links are shown as clear buttons so you can check the underlying material.
3. Check current status
Where a subject changes over time, use the linked official source for the latest published position.
Information & Evidence Shortcuts
Quick access to source links already included in the original RFTUK page.
Full RFTUK Information & Evidence
Purpose of This Hub
Millions of food and drink products are bought in the UK every day. Consumers should be able to find clear information about what products contain, who manufactures them, whether formulations have changed, how ingredients are regulated, and what reliable scientific research says about possible health effects.
This hub brings together manufacturer information, government records, food-safety guidance, scientific databases and health research.
Important Independent Health & Research Disclaimer
Right First Time UK is independent and is not affiliated with any manufacturer, retailer, government department, regulator, university or research organisation linked on this page.
The inclusion of a manufacturer, brand, product or ingredient does not imply wrongdoing or that a product is unsafe.
Scientific evidence can change. Association does not automatically prove causation. Animal, laboratory and observational studies should not be presented as equivalent to high-quality human clinical evidence.
This hub provides general information and research signposting only. It does not provide medical advice, diagnosis or treatment.
How We Rate Research Evidence
Strong Evidence: Consistent findings from high-quality systematic reviews, major evidence assessments or authoritative health guidance.
Moderate Evidence: Reasonably consistent human research, but important uncertainty remains.
Limited or Observational Evidence: Associations have been reported, but cause and effect have not been established.
Early Research: Laboratory, animal, mechanistic or preliminary human research requiring further investigation.
No Reliable Evidence Found: Claims should not be presented as established facts.
What Can the Public Investigate?
- Who manufactures a product?
- Who owns the manufacturer?
- What ingredients does the product currently contain?
- Has the ingredient list changed since 2021?
- Has sugar, salt or saturated fat changed?
- Have sweeteners been introduced?
- Have emulsifiers or preservatives changed?
- Does the product contain palm oil?
- What does independent research say about an ingredient?
- Who funded the research?
- Were conflicts of interest declared?
- What does the Food Standards Agency say?
- Has the product been recalled?
- What health claims are being made?
- What evidence supports those claims?
Choose an Investigation Pathway
How to Investigate a Product
- Photograph the current packaging.
- Record the exact product name and size.
- Record the ingredient list in order.
- Record the nutrition information.
- Find historical packaging or manufacturer information.
- Compare like-for-like products and sizes.
- Record ingredients added or removed.
- Compare sugar, salt, fat and saturated fat.
- Search scientific research for each ingredient.
- Publish sources and dates alongside conclusions.
How to Investigate an Ingredient
- Identify the exact ingredient.
- Check its purpose in food manufacturing.
- Check UK regulatory information.
- Search Food Standards Agency information.
- Search EFSA scientific assessments.
- Search PubMed.
- Search Cochrane reviews.
- Prioritise systematic reviews and human evidence.
- Check funding and conflicts of interest.
- Clearly explain uncertainty.
How to Investigate a Manufacturer
- Identify the manufacturer.
- Identify the ultimate parent company.
- Check Companies House where relevant.
- Check annual reports.
- Check product ingredient pages.
- Check sustainability reports.
- Check lobbying and government meetings where published.
- Check food recalls.
- Check advertising rulings.
- Compare corporate claims with independent evidence.
How to Investigate Scientific Research
- Read the full study where possible.
- Identify whether it studied humans, animals or cells.
- Check sample size.
- Check study duration.
- Check whether it shows association or causation.
- Check funding.
- Check declared conflicts of interest.
- Look for systematic reviews.
- Check whether findings have been replicated.
- Compare conclusions with official scientific assessments.
Investigating Gut Health
Gut-health research examines fibre, dietary diversity, fermented foods, the microbiome, probiotics, prebiotics and the relationship between diet and health.
The microbiome is an active area of research. Consumers should be cautious about claims that one food, supplement or bacterial strain will treat complex diseases.
Investigating Food and Mental Health
Research increasingly examines relationships between dietary patterns and mental wellbeing. Evidence should distinguish broad dietary patterns from claims about individual foods.
Food should not be presented as a replacement for professional mental-health care.
Cadbury, Chocolate & Palm Oil Transparency
Cadbury UK
Investigate current Cadbury products, ingredient information, nutrition and manufacturer information.
Cadbury UKMondelez International
Cadbury is part of Mondelez International. Use corporate reports to investigate ownership, policies and supply chains.
Mondelez InternationalCocoa Beans, Cocoa Solids & Cocoa Butter
Cocoa beans are processed into cocoa ingredients including cocoa solids and cocoa butter. When investigating chocolate, compare the exact ingredients rather than assuming all vegetable oils directly replace cocoa beans.
FAO Cocoa InformationWhat Is Palm Oil?
Palm oil is used in many foods and consumer products. Its role varies according to the product and manufacturing process.
EFSA Palm Oil InformationPalm Oil & Human Health Research
Evidence requires contextResearch should distinguish the nutritional effects of saturated fat, overall dietary patterns, replacement fats, consumption levels and contaminants that may arise during processing.
Search PubMed Research3-MCPD & Glycidyl Esters
Investigate official scientific assessments concerning contaminants that can form during high-temperature processing of some vegetable oils.
EFSA Process ContaminantsPalm Oil Sustainability
Investigate sourcing, deforestation, environmental impacts, certification and manufacturer sustainability claims.
UK Sustainable Palm Oil InformationCadbury Five-Year Ingredient Tracker
Compare archived and current product ingredient information from approximately 2021–2026. Only publish changes supported by dated evidence.
Internet ArchiveFive-Year Product Ingredient Change Tracker
| Manufacturer | Product | 2021 Evidence | Current Evidence | Ingredient Change | Nutrition Change | Evidence Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cadbury / Mondelez | Product under investigation | Add dated archived source | Add current manufacturer source | Record verified additions or removals | Compare like-for-like nutrition | Awaiting verified comparison |
| Manufacturer | Product | Historical ingredient list | Current ingredient list | Document change | Document change | Verified / Unverified |
Major UK Products: 2021 vs 2026 Ingredient Investigation
Tracking Changes to Popular UK Food & Drink Products
This investigation section helps the public compare historical and current ingredients, nutritional information, product sizes and manufacturer information for popular food and drink products consumed in the UK.
The aim is to identify documented changes between approximately 2021 and 2026, including changes to sugar, salt, fat, saturated fat, sweeteners, vegetable oils, palm oil, cocoa ingredients, emulsifiers, preservatives, colours, flavourings and portion sizes.
A product should only be marked as having changed where dated historical evidence can be compared with reliable current information.
Important Product Comparison Warning
Food products can have different formulations in different countries. Manufacturers may also change ingredients without changing the main product name.
Historical and current products must therefore be compared carefully. The same product name, country of sale, product type and serving size should be used wherever possible.
The presence of palm oil, sweeteners, emulsifiers, preservatives or other approved ingredients does not by itself establish that a food is unsafe or harmful. Scientific evidence should be examined separately from the ingredient comparison.
Cadbury Dairy Milk
Investigate changes to one of the UK's most recognised chocolate products.
Compare:
- Milk ingredients
- Sugar
- Cocoa butter
- Cocoa mass
- Vegetable fats where applicable
- Emulsifiers
- Flavourings
- Nutrition per 100g
- Product size
Search Historical Versions
Cadbury Creme Egg
Compare historical and current ingredients used in the chocolate shell and fondant filling.
Investigate:
- Sugar
- Milk ingredients
- Cocoa ingredients
- Vegetable fats
- Emulsifiers
- Glucose syrup
- Colours
- Flavourings
Search Historical Evidence
Cadbury Roses
Investigate the individual chocolates contained within Cadbury Roses and compare ingredient and nutritional changes.
Particular attention can be given to:
- Palm oil
- Other vegetable oils
- Cocoa butter
- Cocoa mass
- Milk ingredients
- Emulsifiers
- Flavourings
- Product weight
Coca-Cola
Compare ingredient lists, nutrition, sugar content and product sizes.
Investigate differences between:
- Coca-Cola Original Taste
- Diet Coke
- Coca-Cola Zero Sugar
Pepsi
Investigate documented changes to UK Pepsi formulations.
Compare:
- Sugar
- Sweeteners
- Caffeine
- Acids
- Flavourings
- Nutrition per 100ml
Lucozade
Investigate historical and current formulations of major Lucozade products.
Compare:
- Sugar content
- Sweeteners
- Caffeine
- Preservatives
- Colours
- Acids
- Product size
Ribena
Investigate ingredient and nutrition changes to major Ribena products.
Compare:
- Blackcurrant content
- Sugar
- Sweeteners
- Preservatives
- Vitamin claims
- Nutrition
Walkers Crisps
Investigate changes to ingredients, cooking oils, salt and product sizes.
Compare:
- Cooking oils
- Potatoes
- Salt
- Flavourings
- MSG where applicable
- Nutrition
- Packet size
Heinz Products
Investigate changes to popular Heinz products including ketchup, baked beans and sauces.
Compare:
- Sugar
- Salt
- Tomato content
- Sweeteners
- Preservatives
- Product sizes
Kellogg's Cereals
Investigate changes to major breakfast cereals consumed by adults and children.
Compare:
- Sugar
- Salt
- Fibre
- Vitamins
- Minerals
- Flavourings
- Product size
Nestlé Cereals
Investigate ingredient and nutritional changes to major Nestlé cereal products.
Compare:
- Wholegrain content
- Sugar
- Salt
- Fibre
- Vitamins
- Minerals
Foods Marketed to Children
Investigate changes to products commonly marketed towards children.
Compare:
- Sugar
- Salt
- Sweeteners
- Colours
- Preservatives
- Portion sizes
- Health claims
- Advertising claims
Baby & Infant Foods
Investigate ingredients, nutrition, sugar content and marketing claims concerning foods intended for babies and young children.
NHS Baby and Weaning GuidancePublic Product Ingredient Comparison Database
How This Database Should Work
Each product investigation should contain dated evidence. Do not simply state that a product has changed. Show the historical evidence, current evidence and exact difference.
| Manufacturer | Product | Historical Year | Historical Ingredients | Current Year | Current Ingredients | What Changed? | Research Links |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cadbury / Mondelez | Cadbury Dairy Milk | 2021 | Add verified historical ingredient list | 2026 | Add verified current ingredient list | Record exact documented changes | Search ingredient research below |
| Cadbury / Mondelez | Cadbury Creme Egg | 2021 | Add historical evidence | 2026 | Add current evidence | Record verified changes | Search ingredient research |
| PepsiCo | Pepsi | 2021 | Add historical evidence | 2026 | Add current evidence | Compare sugar and sweeteners | Search sweetener research |
| Suntory | Lucozade | 2021 | Add historical evidence | 2026 | Add current evidence | Compare formulation | Search caffeine and sweetener research |
| PepsiCo | Walkers Crisps | 2021 | Add historical evidence | 2026 | Add current evidence | Compare oils, salt and portion size | Search nutrition research |
| Kraft Heinz | Heinz Product | 2021 | Add historical evidence | 2026 | Add current evidence | Compare sugar and salt | Search research |
Palm Oil in UK Food Products Investigation
Why Investigate Palm Oil?
Palm oil and palm-derived ingredients are used in many food products. Possible reasons for use include texture, stability, manufacturing characteristics, shelf life and cost.
Palm oil should not simply be described as replacing cocoa beans. Chocolate products may contain cocoa solids, cocoa butter and other vegetable fats for different manufacturing purposes.
The health effects of any food cannot be determined from the presence of one ingredient alone. The amount consumed, overall dietary pattern and what foods or fats are replaced are important considerations.
Saturated Fat
Palm oil contains a significant proportion of saturated fatty acids. Investigate official health guidance and systematic reviews concerning saturated fat and cardiovascular health.
NHS Guidance on FatsEFSA Palm Oil Research
Review scientific assessments concerning palm oil, processing and food contaminants.
EFSA Palm OilPalm Oil Systematic Reviews
Search human research and systematic reviews.
Search PubMedGlycidyl Esters
Investigate contaminants that can form during high-temperature processing of some refined vegetable oils.
EFSA Process Contaminants3-MCPD Esters
Review official scientific assessments and research concerning 3-MCPD fatty acid esters.
Official Scientific InformationEnvironmental Effects of Palm Oil
Investigate deforestation, biodiversity, land use, supply chains and sustainability claims.
UK Government InformationInvestigate the Food in Your Own Home
Public Food Investigation Challenge
Members of the public can investigate products they regularly buy.
- Choose a food or drink product.
- Photograph the front of the packaging.
- Photograph the ingredient list.
- Photograph the nutritional information.
- Record the product size.
- Record the date purchased.
- Search for historical packaging.
- Compare the ingredient lists.
- Check whether the product size changed.
- Search official scientific research about unfamiliar ingredients.
- Check whether research involved humans, animals or laboratory experiments.
- Check who funded the research.
- Publish findings with links to the evidence.
Major Food & Drink Manufacturers
Nestlé UK
Food, confectionery, cereals, coffee and other consumer products.
Nestlé UKUnilever
Major international consumer-goods and food manufacturer.
Unilever UKPepsiCo UK
Drinks, snacks and food brands.
PepsiCo UKCoca-Cola Great Britain
Soft drinks and beverage products.
Coca-Cola GBMars
Confectionery, food and other consumer products.
Mars UKDanone UK
Dairy, plant-based and nutrition products.
Danone UKIngredient Research Library
Sugar Research
Investigate sugar intake, dental health, energy intake and wider health evidence.
NHS Sugar GuidanceArtificial & Non-Sugar Sweeteners
Review safety assessments and health research.
WHO Sweetener GuidanceEmulsifier Research
Developing ResearchInvestigate human, animal and laboratory research concerning emulsifiers and gut health.
PubMed SearchFood Preservatives
Investigate individual preservatives rather than treating all preservatives as one category.
FSA Food AdditivesFood Colours
Check UK regulation and evidence concerning individual colours.
FSA InformationNitrates & Nitrites
Investigate food safety, processed meat and health research.
Research SearchUltra-Processed Foods
Growing Human EvidenceInvestigate definitions, observational findings, trials and scientific debate.
PubMed ResearchCaffeine & Energy Drinks
Investigate caffeine consumption, children, sleep and health.
FSA Caffeine InformationGut Health: What Does Research Investigate?
Dietary Fibre
Strong General Health EvidenceFibre is associated with digestive health and forms part of healthy dietary guidance.
NHS Fibre GuidanceWholegrain Foods
Investigate evidence concerning wholegrains, fibre and health.
Research SearchFermented Food Research
Developing Human EvidenceResearch examines fermented foods, microbial diversity and health.
PubMed ResearchPrebiotic Foods
Research examines substrates used by microorganisms in the gut.
Research SearchProbiotic Research
Effects can vary by strain, dose, population and health condition.
NHS Probiotics GuidanceGut Microbiome Research
A rapidly developing area investigating relationships between microorganisms, diet and health.
PubMed ResearchFoods Commonly Included in Gut-Healthy Dietary Patterns
Research and healthy-eating guidance commonly examine dietary patterns containing vegetables, fruit, wholegrains, beans, pulses, lentils, nuts, seeds and other fibre-rich foods. Some research also examines fermented foods.
The effect of individual foods varies between people. No single food should be presented as a cure for gut disorders.
Food, Diet & Mental Health Research
Diet and Depression Research
Developing EvidenceResearch examines associations and interventions involving dietary patterns and depression.
PubMed ResearchGut-Brain Research
Rapidly Developing FieldResearch examines communication pathways between the digestive system, microbiome and brain.
Research SearchOily Fish & Omega-3 Research
Investigate evidence concerning omega-3 fatty acids, general health and mental health.
Cochrane SearchMediterranean-Style Diet Research
Research examines dietary patterns rich in plant foods, wholegrains and other foods.
Research SearchFruit, Vegetables & Wellbeing
Investigate population studies and intervention research.
PubMed ResearchNHS Healthy Eating Guidance
Official information about balanced diets and healthy eating.
NHS Eat WellFoods Commonly Studied in Healthy Dietary Patterns
- Vegetables
- Fruit
- Beans and pulses
- Wholegrains
- Nuts and seeds
- Oily fish
- Fibre-rich foods
- Some fermented foods
Research generally provides stronger support for balanced overall dietary patterns than claims that one individual food will prevent or treat a mental-health condition.
Official Food Safety, Regulation & Research Sources
Food Standards Agency
Food Standards AgencyFood Alerts & Recalls
FSA AlertsPubMed
Search PubMedCochrane
CochraneEuropean Food Safety Authority
EFSAWorld Health Organization
WHO Healthy DietAdvertising Standards Authority
ASACompanies House
Companies HouseFollow the Research
- Who conducted the study?
- Who funded it?
- Were conflicts of interest declared?
- Did it study humans?
- How many participants were included?
- How long did the study last?
- Was there a control group?
- Was it randomised?
- Was it peer reviewed?
- Has it been replicated?
- Is there a systematic review?
- Does the conclusion match the actual results?
- Did news headlines exaggerate the findings?
Follow the Money
- Who owns the manufacturer?
- Who are the major shareholders?
- How much revenue does the company receive?
- How much is spent on advertising?
- Which organisations receive research funding?
- Which researchers declare industry relationships?
- What lobbying activity is published?
- What government meetings have been disclosed?
- Which trade associations represent the manufacturer?
- What sustainability claims are made?
- How are ingredients sourced?
Suggested Public Information & FOI Investigations
- Government meetings with major food manufacturers.
- Correspondence concerning food reformulation policy.
- Research commissioned by government departments.
- Food-industry representation on advisory groups.
- Records concerning sugar and salt reduction programmes.
- Correspondence concerning artificial sweeteners.
- Government records concerning ultra-processed food policy.
- Food-safety research contracts.
- Records concerning children's food advertising.
- Government meetings concerning energy drinks.
Responsible Food & Health Transparency
- Do not claim an ingredient causes disease without reliable evidence.
- Do not present association as proof of causation.
- Distinguish animal studies from human research.
- Distinguish laboratory research from real-world health outcomes.
- Check product ingredients directly.
- Record the date evidence was accessed.
- Compare identical products and serving sizes.
- Distinguish ingredient changes from nutrition changes.
- Check who funded research.
- Report uncertainty fairly.
- Give manufacturers a fair opportunity to respond to serious criticism.
- Correct outdated information promptly.